Peyton Manning, not Tom Brady, is definitely the GOAT, in keeping with PFR’s Corridor of Fame monitor metric


One of many primary narratives following Tremendous Bowl LV was Tom Brady’s undisputed declare because the NFL‘s GOAT. Even all-world receiver Jerry Rice conceded that title to Brady, who gained his seventh Tremendous Bowl and fifth Tremendous Bowl MVP at age 43. Whereas Brady’s standing because the GOAT can nonetheless be debated, his longevity and sustained excellence is really peerless. 

That being stated, Brady isn’t the GOAT in the case of a Professional Soccer Reference metric. The web site created a “Corridor of Fame Monitor” in 2019 that was designed to estimate a participant’s possibilities at being inducted into the Professional Soccer Corridor of Fame. Utilizing approximate worth, Professional Bowls, All-Execs, championships and different statistical milestones, the location created some extent system to find out the pecking order at every place. 

At quarterback, Peyton Manning holds the highest spot with 258 factors. Brady is No. 2 with 250.94 factors, adopted by Brett Favre (178.84 factors), Aaron Rodgers (163.72 factors), Johnny Unitas (169.34 factors), Joe Montana (153.45 factors), Drew Brees (140.5 factors), John Elway (137.78 factors), Fran Tarkenton (117.28 factors), and Dan Marino (116.85 factors). Whereas Brady has 5 extra rings than Manning, Manning’s two titles, 5 MVP awards (in comparison with Brady’s three) and 7 All-Professional picks (in comparison with three for Brady) offers him a slight edge in the intervening time. However whereas Manning’s profession is about to be immortalized in Canton, Ohio, Brady can add to his level tally within the coming seasons. 

Philip Rivers, who introduced his retirement following the Colts‘ playoff loss to Buffalo, is definitely twelfth on Professional Soccer’s QB Corridor of Fame metric with 97.64 factors. He is simply behind Steve Younger (112.98 factors) and forward of Barr Starr (97.53 factors), Matt Ryan (97.43 factors), and Ben Roethlisberger (95.38 factors). 

Eli Manning, in case you have been questioning, is twenty first on the record with 83.41 factors. Whereas his level tally is properly wanting the Corridor of Fame common, Manning’s rating is greater than Corridor of Famers Joe Namath (82.5 factors), Bob Griese (73.45 factors), Troy Aikman (64.85 factors), and Jim Kelly (59.1 factors), amongst others. He additionally has extra factors than present Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson (74.2 factors). 

Whereas Brady can nonetheless catch Manning, Rice’s place atop the huge receiver meals chain is fairly safe. Rice’s 311.81 factors are greater than twice as many because the second-ranked receiver, Randy Moss (149.59 factors). Whereas Moss’ 23 landing catches in 2007 stays a single-season report, Rice’s three rings, 10 All-Professional picks (in comparison with 4 for Moss) and 13 Professional Bowls (Moss was a six-time Professional Bowler) put him in a category by himself. 

This is a take a look at the top-five gamers at every place, in keeping with Professional Soccer Reference’s Corridor of Fame Monitor. We’ll additionally embrace present gamers who’re near the typical level whole for Corridor of Famers at their place. 


Peyton Manning — 258 factors

Tom Brady — 250.94 factors 

Brett Favre — 178.84 factors 

Aaron Rodgers — 163.72 factors 

Johnny Unitas — 160.34 factors 

Common level tally for HOF quarterbacks: 104 

Notable present gamers: Matt Ryan (97.43 factors), Ben Roethlisberger (95.38 factors), Russell Wilson (74.20 factors) 

Working again 

Walter Payton — 214.91 factors 

Jim Brown — 182.41 factors 

Barry Sanders — 178.05 factors 

Emmitt Smith — 176.30 factors 

LaDainian Tomlinson — 136.15 factors 

Common level whole for HOF working backs: 107

Notable present gamers: Adrian Peterson (123.85 factors), Frank Gore (100.05 factors), LeSean McCoy (83.14 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: Brown led the NFL in dashing for eight of his 9 seasons. His 1,863-yard season in 1963 was probably the most ever at the moment. 

Large receiver

Jerry Rice — 311.81 factors 

Randy Moss — 149.59 factors 

Marvin Harrison — 147.60 factors 

Larry Fitzgerald — 140.92 factors

Terrell Owens — 139.83 factors 

Common level whole for HOF huge receivers: 105 

Notable present gamers: Fitzgerald, Julio Jones (100.82 factors), Antonio Brown (98.7 factors)

Fascinating nugget: In simply 12 video games, Rice caught 22 landing passes in 1987, which stood on the single-season report till Moss caught 23 touchdowns in 2007. 

Tight finish 

Tony Gonzalez — 196.33 factors 

Antonio Gates — 113.63 factors 

Shannon Sharpe — 113.23 factors 

Dave Casper — 111.62 factors 

Jason Witten — 105.62 factors 

Common level whole for HOF tight ends: 98 

Notable present gamers: Rob Gronkowski (89.51 factors), Travis Kelce (73.16 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: Of the top-five tight ends on this record, solely Sharpe and Casper performed on Tremendous Bowl-winning groups. Sharpe gained back-to-back titles with the Broncos; Casper caught a landing go within the Raiders‘ win over Minnesota in Tremendous Bowl XI. 


Bruce Matthews — 158.7 factors 

John Hannah — 153.1 factors 

Randall McDaniel — 148.75 factors 

Alan Faneca — 134.23 factors 

Larry Little — 133.73 factors 

Common level whole for HOF guards: 110 

Notable present gamers: Zack Martin (67.78 factors), David DeCastro (44.33 factors), Mike Iupati (37.43 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: 5 of Matthews’ 14 Professional Bowl picks got here at middle, as Matthews briefly switched positions halfway by means of his profession. 

Offensive deal with 

Anthony Munoz — 160.65 factors 

Forrest Gregg — 139.5 factors 

Jim Parker — 121.25 factors 

Ron Yary — 120.18 factors 

Willie Roaf — 117.3 factors 

Common level whole for HOF offensive deal with: 101 

Notable present gamers: Jason Peters (89.7 factors), Tyron Smith (73 factors), Andrew Whitworth (59.65 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: Gregg, a key member of the Packers‘ Nineteen Sixties dynasty, really coached Munoz in Cincinnati from 1980-83. The duo helped the Bengals attain their first Tremendous Bowl in 1981. 


Dermontti Dawson — 128.23 factors 

Jim Otto — 124.78 factors 

Mike Webster — 117.6 factors 

Dwight Stephenson — 111.95 factors 

Kevin Mawae — 99.05 factors 

Common level whole for HOF facilities: 109 

Notable present gamers: **Maurkice Pouncey (73.78 factors), Alex Mack (64.58 factors), Jason Kelce (51.28 factors)

** — Pouncey retired following the 2020 season 

Fascinating nugget: Dawson succeeded Webster in Pittsburgh following Webster’s departure for Kansas Metropolis in 1989. For a 25-year span, the Steelers had a top-five all-time middle manning their offensive line.  

Defensive deal with 

Bob Lilly — 159.2 factors 

Alan Web page — 157.1 factors 

Randy White — 142.18 factors 

Joe Greene — 136.53 factors 

John Randle — 135.6 factors 

Common level whole for HOF defensive tackles: 114 factors 

Notable present gamers: Aaron Donald (127.63 factors), Ndamukong Suh (79.98 factors), Geno Atkins (75.85 factors), Fletcher Cox (71.98 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: Web page grew to become the primary defensive participant to win league MVP in 1971. Whereas he by no means gained league MVP, Greene succeeded Web page as Defensive Participant of the Yr in 1972. He gained the glory for a second time in 1974, whereas additionally profitable the primary of 4 Tremendous Bowls over a six-year span. 

Defensive finish 

Reggie White — 237.75 factors 

Bruce Smith — 211.35 factors 

Jack Youngblood — 124.15 factors 

J.J. Watt — 123.88 factors 

Michael Strahan — 123.6 factors 

Common level whole for HOF defensive ends: 103 

Notable present gamers: Watt, Calais Campbell (77.58 factors), Cameron Jordan (69.1 factors), Chandler Jones (62.63 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: The NFL’s first massive free agent signee, White helped ship Inexperienced Bay’s first title in 29 years along with his three-sack effort within the Packers’ win over the Patriots in Tremendous Bowl XXXI. 

Inside linebacker 

Ray Lewis — 197.03 factors 

Mike Singletary — 171 factors 

Jack Lambert — 151.65 factors 

Dick Butkus — 128.85 factors 

Luke Kuechly — 118.4 factors 

Common level whole for HOF inside linebackers: 114 

Notable present gamers: Bobby Wagner (96.68 factors), Ok.J. Wright (35.4 factors), Sean Lee (26.5 factors)

Fascinating nugget: Butkus and Kuechly weren’t penalized for having comparatively quick careers. Butkus retired after 9 seasons and 119 profession video games. Kuechly performed eight seasons and in 118 common season video games earlier than retiring after the 2019 season. 

Outdoors linebacker 

Lawrence Taylor — 215.68 factors 

Derrick Brooks — 162.8 factors 

Jack Ham — 143.7 factors 

Ted Hendricks — 137.35 factors 

Junior Seau — 119.58 factors 

Common level whole for outdoor linebackers: 106 

Notable present gamers: Khalil Mack (83.35 factors), Lavonte David (42.45 factors), Justin Houston (39.25 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: Taylor joined Web page because the NFL’s solely defensive league MVPs in 1986. He led the NFL with 20.5 sacks that season whereas additionally main the Giants to their first Tremendous Bowl title. 

Defensive again

Rod Woodson — 118.05 factors

Deion Sanders — 174.43 factors 

Ronnie Lott — 173.75 factors 

Ed Reed — 150.4 factors 

Willie Wooden — 130.73 factors 

Common level whole for Corridor of Fame defensive backs: 106

Notable present gamers: Richard Sherman (79.38 factors), Patrick Peterson (78.95 factors), Chris Harris Jr. (60.1 factors), Stephon Gilmore (57.65 factors), Tyrann Mathieu (54.5 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: In 1995, Woodson made NFL historical past by changing into the primary skilled athlete to return from reconstructive knee surgical procedure in the identical season. Woodson performed in Tremendous Bowl XXX after struggling a torn ACL in Week 1. 


Morten Anderson — 97.45 factors 

Adam Vinatieri — 92.7 factors 

Gary Anderson — 65.9 factors 

Nick Lowery — 57.63 factors 

Jan Stenerud — 56.53 factors 

Common level whole for Corridor of Fame kickers: 77 

Notable curent gamers: Justin Tucker (45.9 factors), Stephen Gostkowski (44.13 factors), Robbie Gould (22.58 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: Whereas Vinatieri’s two game-winning discipline objectives are a part of NFL lore, Morten Anderson’s game-winning extra time discipline purpose within the 1998 NFC Championship Sport gave the Falcons an inconceivable win over the Vikings and Gary Anderson, who missed a important 38-yard discipline purpose earlier within the recreation. 


Shane Lechler — 63.68 factors 

Ray Man — 52.33 factors 

Sean Landeta — 47.23 factors 

Don Chandler — 37.45 factors 

Johnny Hekker — 30.08 factors 

Common level whole for Corridor of Fame Punters: 52

Notable present gamers: Hekker, Andy Lee (23.5 factors), Dustin Colquitt (16.85 factors) 

Fascinating nugget: The primary punter inducted in Canton, Man was chosen to seven Professional Bowls throughout his time with the Raiders. He was the beginning punter on every of the Raiders’ three Tremendous Bowl championship groups. 



Leave a Reply